No Boundaries and Naturally-Defined Boundaries Obtained via the Electrostatic Potential

Abstract

This paper discusses the use of the electrostatic potential in both recent and older literature, with an emphasis upon a 2022 Molecular Physics article by Politzer and Murray entitled ”Atoms do exist in molecules: analysis using electrostatic potentials at nuclei”. We discuss electrostatic potentials at nuclei and how they easily lead to atoms in molecules, without physically separating the individual atoms. We further summarize the work by the Politzer group on definitions of atomic radii by means of the electrostatic potential. The earlier studies began in the 1970’s and continued through the 1990’s. Unfortunately, access to these older publications is often limited, cfr. digital libraries often limit the authorized access until a certain publication year, and these papers are often not cited in current publications. Although still being highly interesting and relevant, this older literature is in danger of being lost. Digging into this older literature thus opens up new views. Our feeling is that Peter passed ‘on’ a vision that boundaries do not exist between atoms in molecules, but that some useful and meaningful radii can be obtained using the electrostatic potential between atoms in molecules.